Key Payers Denied Your Application Citing Their Network Is Closed – Now What?

Published in Government Relations on April 30, 2025

By Melanie Ewald, VP of Payer Relations and Reimbursement, VGM 

This experience has increasingly become one of the most common questions we receive from our provider members as more and more payers move to narrow their provider networks. The reasons payers seek to narrow their networks are simple. Payers are highly motivated to achieve their goals while doing less work and are not required to allow providers into their networks unless there is a patient access issue. For those of you fortunate enough to be a part of a narrow network, this may not be much of an issue for you.  

For those on the outside trying to get in, this can appear to be of great concern and detriment to your business. The answer in both scenarios is highly individualized to each business and is dependent on several variables such as the payer, type of contract, reimbursement rates, the administrative burden on you as the provider to provide the service, etc. That said, the strategy for maintaining in-network status and getting into a closed network are similar. 

There is no question the process of contracting with payers can be very challenging. Unfortunately, the days when payers would offer contracts to any interested provider are gone. Providers must now demonstrate to payers a justified argument as to why the payer should add them to their network. Below are some best practices for contracting when a payer denies an application citing closed network. 

Expose gaps in the payer’s existing network and be the solution. 

Review the payer’s provider network in your categories to identify gaps in the existing network. Network gaps may include any variety of issues such as: 1) Inadequate geographic coverage such that the in-network providers are not able to provide service to a location that you are able to reach; 2) Limitations in product scope that either a) unreasonably limit patient choice or, b) simply prohibit patients from obtaining a product due to the in-network provider not carrying it; and 3) Place of service limitations causing some patients to not receive services because in-network providers will not provide services in that setting. Take some time to analyze your situation to identify any other differentiators or gaps that you can help fill that are currently an issue with the payer’s network. 

Establish and convey your value proposition to the payer. 

In addition to identifying gaps in a payer’s network, you must also show payers why you should be added to their provider network through the value you bring. Do you offer a unique product or service not obtained elsewhere? Do you provide service or reliable outcomes data that other providers do not, resulting in quantifiable outcomes for the patients you serve? Include these important differentiators when demonstrating your value proposition. Just be mindful that your value proposition shows that your network inclusion is at least neutral to the plan administratively to avoid being seen as an additional administrative burden. 

Engage help from physicians, facilities, employer groups, etc. 

Your referral source relationships (e.g., physicians, hospitals, rehabilitation, SNFs, long-term care facilities, etc.) can play a critical role in obtaining access to a payer’s closed network. As you earn their trust and become their preferred DME provider for their patients, referral sources are often willing to provide letters of support or make calls to payers on your behalf to advocate for your admittance to the network.  

Gather and provide data. 

You likely have several sources of data at your fingertips that, once quantified, will further demonstrate your value and make the case for you to be allowed into the network. Examples of these data sources can include things like quantifying the number of the payer’s members that come independently or are referred to you on a monthly basis that you have to turn away or bill out of network. When you bill out of network and are able to secure single case agreement, quantifying the number of those agreements demonstrates the need for the payer to add you to their network. Other examples include quantifying and calling out any situations where patients are not able to obtain services due to a cap in coverage. 

Today’s payer contracting environment requires providers to continuously find ways to demonstrate their value to payers. The contracting process can be a time-intensive exercise with mixed results. You must be diligent in following up on your communication with payers and respond timely to their requests for additional information.  

While the above outlines a proven approach for overturning payer contracting denials due to a closed network status, payers still have the discretion to add or deny provider network access. In addition, as mentioned above, not all contracts are created equal or worth it at the end of the day. Being selective about where you spend your valuable resources is critical to any contracting strategy. 

From Our Experts

Mike Hamilton Of ADMEA Honored With The Mal Mixon Advocate Award thumbnail Mike Hamilton Of ADMEA Honored With The Mal Mixon Advocate Award Last week, during the 2025 AAHomecare Washington Legislative Conference, Mike Hamilton, Executive Director of ADMEA, was honored with the prestigious Mal Mixon Advocate Award. VGM Senior Leaders Engage in Advocacy at AAHomecare Legislative Conference thumbnail VGM Senior Leaders Engage in Advocacy at AAHomecare Legislative Conference This week, VGM leaders attended the AAHomecare Legislative Conference in Washington, D.C., a premier event dedicated to advancing healthcare policy and advocacy. AAHomecare provided attendees with valuable insights, equipping them with key discussion points and strategies for effective meetings with legislators. Champion of Change: Paula Vineyard of Elana Health & Loop Medical Leads Healthcare Advocacy in West Virginia thumbnail Champion of Change: Paula Vineyard of Elana Health & Loop Medical Leads Healthcare Advocacy in West Virginia On Thursday, May 8, Paula Vineyard, owner of Elana Health & Loop Medical, took a pivotal step in healthcare advocacy by hosting a meeting with Tyler Ohrn, Field Representative for Congresswoman Carol Miller of West Virginia's First District. The hour-long discussion centered on the pressing need for congressional support of H.R. 2005. Manufacturer Survey On Tariffs thumbnail Manufacturer Survey On Tariffs The American Association for Homecare and VGM Group are seeking valuable insights from durable medical equipment, prosthetics, orthotics, and supplies (DMEPOS) manufacturers and vendor partners regarding tariffs imposed on certain countries. Congress Returns: Medicaid Cuts Take Center Stage thumbnail Congress Returns: Medicaid Cuts Take Center Stage Congress is back in session after a two-week recess. Number one on the docket is figuring out the budget. The house is tasked with coming up with a $1.5 trillion reduction and a key committee is in the spotlight. The DMEPOS Relief Act Of 2025 – WE NEED YOUR HELP! thumbnail The DMEPOS Relief Act Of 2025 – WE NEED YOUR HELP! The DMEPOS Relief Act of 2025 (or H.R. 2005) is bipartisan legislation that was recently introduced in Congress designed to increase reimbursement for a large percentage of HME providers across the country. This bill establishes a higher reimbursement rate (known as the 75/25 blended rate) for durable medical equipment in nonrural/noncompetitive bidding areas under Medicare until Dec. 31, 2025. Champion Of Change: Lauryn Estrella Speaks On Tariffs Impacting HME Providers And Patients thumbnail Champion Of Change: Lauryn Estrella Speaks On Tariffs Impacting HME Providers And Patients Today, we shine a spotlight on Lauryn Estrella, the dedicated Executive Director of Home Medical Equipment and Services Association of New England (HOMES) and a true Champion of Change in the HME industry. Ensuring Access To Care: The Fight For Permanent Telehealth Flexibilities thumbnail Ensuring Access To Care: The Fight For Permanent Telehealth Flexibilities Americans utilizing telehealth services to access healthcare is at an all-time high. It's a convenient method without having to leave the home, giving access to healthcare professionals from anywhere. It expands a patient's choice of provider and enables the provider the ability to see more patients.