Uncovering Denials: OIG Reports Reveal Alarming Trends in Medicaid Managed Care Plans

Published in Government Relations on August 25, 2023

In 2022, the OIG released a report outlining their findings which concluded that Medicare Advantage plans were routinely denying authorizations requests and claims for items that would be covered by traditional Medicare Fee For Service (FFS). On July 17, 2023, the OIG released a similar report which shows something similar may be happening within Medicaid Manage Care plans. The three main things that they concluded from their research was that within Medicaid managed care programs:

  1. A high number and rate of denied prior authorization (PA) requests by some MCOs, some of which very likely should have been approved,
  2. limited oversight of prior authorization denials in most States, and
  3. limited access to external medical reviews and a cumbersome appeal and/or state fair hearing process, which may deter providers and or Medicaid patients from pursuing that option.

While conducting their analysis, the OIG looked at authorization and claims data from seven parent companies, namely Molina, CareSource, UHC, Centene, Anthem/Elevance, Aetna, and AmeriHealth Caritas. These parent companies represent 115 Medicaid MCOs in 37 states and cover nearly 30 million people[AR1] , roughly 36% of the total number of Medicaid lives. Some additional findings and statistics from the OIG’s Medicaid report included:

  • MCOs denied one out of eight (12.5%) requests for prior authorization (PA) in 2019.
  • MCOs fully or partially denied approximately 2.2 million PA requests in 2019.
  • 12 MCOs had PA denial rates greater than 25%—twice the overall rate.
  • Most State Medicaid agencies reported that they did not routinely review the appropriateness of a sample of MCO denials of PA requests.
  • Many states did not collect and monitor data on these decisions.
  • Absence of oversight of MCO decisions on PA requests presents a limitation that can allow inappropriate denials to go undetected in Medicaid managed care.
  • Most State Medicaid agencies reported they do not have a mechanism for patients or providers to submit a PA denial to an external medical reviewer independent of the MCO.
  • Although all State Medicaid agencies are required to offer State fair hearings as an appeal option, these administrative hearings may be difficult to navigate and burdensome on Medicaid patients. The OIG reported that Medicaid enrollees appealed only a small portion of PA denials to either their MCOs or to State fair hearings.
  • Seven of Molina’s 12 MCOs had PA denial rates greater than 25%.

As many of you are aware, VGM has participated in several meetings and discussions with CMS over the past 12 months around the topics of improper denials of PA and claims within managed Medicare and managed Medicaid, general lack of oversight for these plans, and overall network adequacy. We will continue to use findings like the ones outlined above along with other examples provided by our members to continue our discussions with CMS representatives, with the goal being to reduce or eliminate these issues within managed care in the future. Please continue to provide us with those examples of improper denials and access-to-care issues resulting from inadequate provider networks.

From Our Experts

The Return of Competitive Bidding thumbnail The Return of Competitive Bidding The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) appear to be laying the groundwork for another round of the Competitive Bidding Program (CBP). While full implementation will take a couple of years, an official announcement is expected this summer—potentially as early as July. Out With The Old RAC, In With The New thumbnail Out With The Old RAC, In With The New On April 28, 2025, CMS awarded Cotiviti GOV Services LLC, the new RAC Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC) Region 3, 4, and 5 contracts. RAC Region 3 includes the following Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) jurisdictions: JJ, JM, and JN. RAC Region 4 includes jurisdictions: JE, JF, and JL. And RAC Region 5 includes jurisdictions: JA, JB, JC, JD, as well as the HH/H MACs: J6, J15, JK, and JM. Iowa Leads the Charge! All Four Representatives Back H.R. 2005—Will Your State Step Up? thumbnail Iowa Leads the Charge! All Four Representatives Back H.R. 2005—Will Your State Step Up? At VGM Group, Inc. we have the pleasure of serving our members and partners throughout the country.  One of the many ways we do this is through legislative advocacy, working with our partners to create a more equitable and effective healthcare system. All our VGM units are dedicated to advancing our partners' businesses, streamlining operations, and working every day to enhance reimbursement for the quality in-home healthcare our industry provides all people. Mike Hamilton Of ADMEA Honored With The Mal Mixon Advocate Award thumbnail Mike Hamilton Of ADMEA Honored With The Mal Mixon Advocate Award Last week, during the 2025 AAHomecare Washington Legislative Conference, Mike Hamilton, Executive Director of ADMEA, was honored with the prestigious Mal Mixon Advocate Award. VGM Senior Leaders Engage in Advocacy at AAHomecare Legislative Conference thumbnail VGM Senior Leaders Engage in Advocacy at AAHomecare Legislative Conference This week, VGM leaders attended the AAHomecare Legislative Conference in Washington, D.C., a premier event dedicated to advancing healthcare policy and advocacy. AAHomecare provided attendees with valuable insights, equipping them with key discussion points and strategies for effective meetings with legislators. Champion of Change: Paula Vineyard of Elana Health & Loop Medical Leads Healthcare Advocacy in West Virginia thumbnail Champion of Change: Paula Vineyard of Elana Health & Loop Medical Leads Healthcare Advocacy in West Virginia On Thursday, May 8, Paula Vineyard, owner of Elana Health & Loop Medical, took a pivotal step in healthcare advocacy by hosting a meeting with Tyler Ohrn, Field Representative for Congresswoman Carol Miller of West Virginia's First District. The hour-long discussion centered on the pressing need for congressional support of H.R. 2005. Manufacturer Survey On Tariffs thumbnail Manufacturer Survey On Tariffs The American Association for Homecare and VGM Group are seeking valuable insights from durable medical equipment, prosthetics, orthotics, and supplies (DMEPOS) manufacturers and vendor partners regarding tariffs imposed on certain countries. Key Payers Denied Your Application Citing Their Network Is Closed – Now What? thumbnail Key Payers Denied Your Application Citing Their Network Is Closed – Now What? This experience has increasingly become one of the most common questions we receive from our provider members as more and more payers move to narrow their provider networks. The reasons payers seek to narrow their networks are simple. Payers are highly motivated to achieve their goals while doing less work and are not required to allow providers into their networks unless there is a patient access issue. For those of you fortunate enough to be a part of a narrow network, this may not be much of